Why Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE) Leads the Pack: A Comprehensive Comparison of Managed Kubernetes Services

This article discusses potential issues companies may encounter when using Kubernetes for their workloads and highlights the unique features and advantages of Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE) compared to other managed Kubernetes services. It focuses on performance benchmarking parameters to illustrate GKE’s benefits.

Additionally, this article provides a detailed comparison of GKE with other services such as Azure Kubernetes Service, Elastic Kubernetes Service, OVHCloud Kubernetes, DigitalOcean Kubernetes, IBM Kubernetes Service, and Red Hat OpenShift, summarizing key differences in features and performance.

Who should read this?

• IT decision-makers and CTOs
• Cloud infrastructure and operations managers
• DevOps engineers and Kubernetes administrators
• Companies currently using or considering Kubernetes
• Enterprises looking to optimize cloud costs and performance
• Technology consulting firms

What are the challenges faced with Kubernetes?

• Managing Cluster Upgrades: Frequent upgrades in Kubernetes can be disruptive and require significant planning to avoid downtime and maintain stability.
• High Cost of Kubernetes Operations: Running Kubernetes clusters can be expensive, especially when considering long-term operations and scaling.
• Complex Lifecycle Management of Configuration Syncs: Managing the lifecycle of Config Sync components manually can be error-prone and time-consuming.
• Efficiently Running AI/ML Workloads: High-performance AI/ML workloads require specialized hardware and optimized orchestration to be cost-effective. Setting up and maintaining GPU drivers can be complex and time-consuming.
• Achieving Kubernetes Compliance: Ensuring compliance with industry standards and benchmarks can be challenging and resource-intensive.
• Monitoring and Alerting for Resource Quotas: Lack of visibility into scalability limits can lead to unexpected resource constraints and operational issues.
• Managing Stateful Workloads: Stateful workloads typically require reliable and high-performance storage solutions.
• Handling Burstable Workloads: Workloads that occasionally exceed their resource requests can cause instability or incur unexpected costs.
• High Throughput and Low Latency Requirements: Ensuring high throughput and low latency networking can be challenging in large-scale Kubernetes deployments.
• Efficient IP Management: Managing IP addresses efficiently is critical to avoid conflicts and optimize traffic.
• Secure Inter-Region Connectivity: Maintaining secure and high-performance connectivity between regions can be difficult.
• Implementing Advanced Network Policies: Enforcing fine-grained network policies at scale can be complex.
• Observability of Kubernetes Clusters: Running observability tools like ECK on Kubernetes can be complex and require extensive manual setup.

Comparison between Managed Kubernetes Services

Key-focus Areas

• Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE): GKE excels in integrating open-source tools to provide leading scalability, security, and observability.
• Azure Kubernetes Service (AKS): AKS focuses on automated management and enterprise scalability.
• Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS): EKS leverages AWS’s infrastructure for high performance and customization.
• OVHcloud Kubernetes: OVHcloud Kubernetes prioritizes data sovereignty and compliance with European regulations.
• DigitalOcean Kubernetes: DigitalOcean Kubernetes (DOKS) is designed for simplicity and ease of use, providing an accessible, cost-effective solution for developers and small teams.
• IBM Kubernetes Service (IKS): IBM Kubernetes Service supports multi-cloud and hybrid environments, integrating enterprise-grade security and AI/ML capabilities with IBM Cloud and other providers.
• Red Hat OpenShift Kubernetes: OpenShift excels in hybrid and multi-cloud deployments with a strong commitment to open-source tools and enterprise-grade security.

GKE users can benefit from TPU v5e’s capabilities in orchestrating AI workloads effectively.

Features of GKE That Sets Itself Apart

• GKE Extended Support: Starting with version 1.27, GKE clusters can remain officially supported for up to 24 months on a specific GKE minor version. After the 14-month standard support period, clusters transition into a 10-month extended support period where they continue to receive security patches. This feature provides businesses with greater flexibility in managing their cluster upgrade cycles.
• Compute Flexible CUD Expansion: Google has expanded its Compute Engine Flexible CUD, referred to as the Compute Flexible CUD, to cover Cloud Run on-demand resources, most GKE Autopilot Pods, and the premiums for Autopilot Performance and Accelerator compute classes. This allows for significant cost savings, up to 46% for a three-year commitment and 28% for a one-year commitment, by covering eligible spending across Compute Engine, GKE, and Cloud Run with a single CUD purchase.
• Config Sync AutoUpgrades: This feature, available in the preview, allows automatic upgrades of Config Sync versions and simplifies the lifecycle management of Config Sync components. Available for GKE Enterprise clusters with Config Sync enabled, this feature can be enabled through the Google Cloud console or gcloud commands for individual clusters or fleetwide.
• Cloud TPU v5e on GKE: GKE supports Cloud TPU v5e, Google’s purpose-built AI accelerator, offering enhanced cost efficiency and performance for large-scale model training and inference. GKE users can benefit from TPU v5e’s capabilities in orchestrating AI workloads effectively.
• GKE Autopilot Support for Elastic Cloud on Kubernetes (ECK): This partnership with Elastic enables customers to run ECK on GKE in Autopilot mode, taking advantage of both platforms’ benefits, such as fully managed Kubernetes experience, just-in-time scalability, and reduced TCO.
• GKE Compliance: This fully managed, built-in feature for GKE Enterprise simplifies Kubernetes compliance by allowing users to assess clusters and workloads against industry standards and benchmarks, including the CIS Benchmark for GKE and Pod Security Standards. The service provides a centralized compliance reporting dashboard updated every 30 minutes, simplifying compliance posture management.
• Automatic NVIDIA GPU Driver Installation: GKE simplifies using NVIDIA GPUs for AI/ML workloads by automatically installing and maintaining the necessary GPU drivers, streamlining the process for users.
• GKE Quota Monitoring and Alerting: Users gain more control over their GKE scaling by introducing direct monitoring and alerting for scalability limits. This feature provides deeper insight into the Kubernetes environment and can be accessed through the Google Cloud console.
• Hyperdisk Balanced for GKE: This new storage option suits stateful workloads like line-of-business applications, web apps, and databases that typically rely on persistent SSDs. Hyperdisk Balanced offers customizable capacity, throughput, and IOPS performance and is compatible with 3rd+ generation instance types.
• GKE Autopilot Burstable Workloads: GKE Autopilot supports burstable workloads, enabling Pods to utilize resources beyond their request and billing temporarily. This feature, powered by GKE Autopilot’s unique design on Google Cloud, allows for greater flexibility and cost optimization.

15 Reasons Why Customers Should Use GKE

1. Rapid Deployment: GKE’s fast cluster setup time allows teams to get their environments up and running quickly, reducing time to market. Quick startup times for new pods enhance application responsiveness and reduce downtime.
2. Scalability: With support for up to 15,000 nodes per cluster, GKE is ideal for large-scale deployments and growing businesses. GKE’s scaling capabilities are unmatched with support for both HPA and VPA, alongside node auto-provisioning, ensuring efficient resource management, and can effortlessly handle large-scale deployments, making it ideal for dynamic workloads.
3. Advanced Networking: GKE’s use of Calico for network policies and Google’s highly optimized global network ensures superior networking performance and security. GKE offers advanced networking features, including VPC-native clusters, support for Istio, and global load balancing. These features ensure high performance, security, and seamless integration for service management and traffic control across multiple clusters.
4. Ease of Management: Fully managed Istio integration simplifies the deployment and management of a service mesh, enabling advanced traffic management and observability with minimal overhead. GKE’s built-in support for Istio ensures seamless service-to-service communication and management.
5. AI/ML Support: GKE offers seamless integration with Vertex AI, providing a powerful platform for developing and deploying machine learning models.
6. Hybrid/Multi-cloud: GKE’s Enterprise version enables hybrid and multi-cloud deployments, allowing organizations to manage workloads across multiple environments seamlessly.
7. Pricing: GKE offers cost-effective and granular pricing options, allowing optimization of costs based on resource usage. It also offers various cost-saving options, including sustained use discounts and Spot VMs, making it a cost-effective solution.
8. Availability: GKE offers high (99.95%) availability with multi-region support, ensuring reliable performance for critical applications.
9. Container Runtime: GKE supports Container-Optimized OS and gVisor, enhancing container security and performance.
10. Storage Options: GKE provides robust storage solutions with Persistent Disk, Filestore, and Cloud Storage, supporting diverse data storage needs.
11. Commitment to Open Source: GKE stands out with its strong support for open-source container tools, ensuring compatibility and flexibility for developers.
12. Windows Container Support: GKE’s support for Windows Server containers facilitates mixed OS environments, providing versatility for diverse workloads.
13. Security: With comprehensive security features including Google Security Command Center, IAM integration, and Binary Authorization, GKE ensures robust security for your Kubernetes workloads. The support for confidential computing and Shielded GKE Nodes further enhances data protection.
14. Observability: GKE’s observability tools, including Cloud Operations and integration with managed Prometheus and Grafana, offer real-time logging, monitoring, and tracing, advanced observability, and real-time insights into cluster performance. This provides comprehensive visibility into cluster operations and helps in proactive issue resolution.
15. Multi-Arch Support: GKE’s full support for multi-architecture deployments (x86 and Arm64) along with seamless multi-cloud and hybrid cloud operations with GKE Enterprise, positions it as a versatile and future-ready Kubernetes platform.

Why Google’s Networking Parameters Make GKE the Best

• High Throughput and Low Latency: Achieve up to 32 Gbps per VM and less than 1 millisecond intra-region latency for high-performance networking.
• Scalable Packet Rate: Support up to 3 million packets per second (pps) per VM, scaling with the number of vCPUs for efficient packet processing.
• Global Load Balancing: Sub-millisecond latency for load balancing and support for millions of requests per second enhance application availability and performance.
• Efficient IP Management: VPC-native (Alias IP) and Network Endpoint Groups (NEGs) provide optimized traffic management and efficient IP address allocation.
• Secure and High-Performance Inter-Region Connectivity: Dedicated Interconnect with up to 80 Gbps and low latency ensures reliable global communication, while Cloud VPN offers up to 3 Gbps per tunnel with high availability.
• Advanced Network Policies: Integration with Calico for fine-grained policy enforcement and scalability supports large and complex network policies.

Subscribe to The Cloud Pilot

Follow me on LinkedIn: Udesh Udayakumar

Thanks for reading! The Cloud Pilot, signing off…